Rachel's: A Fire Island Bakery

A Bakery Proudly Founded in Fire Island in 1975

Rachel's Fire Island Restaurant and Bakery is a mainstay for many in the Fire Island and Ocean Beach area on Long Island, New York. If you know our history, you know that we began as a small bakery, but have become something much more! Proudly founded in 1975, our bakery has been serving the Fire Island community with delicious snacks and treats for decades. And now our little storefront is also a full restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner. So you have the option to come down and eat a full meal. We have delicious menus for each type of meal, but you can also simply choose one of our delicious baked goods and pastries from the bakery! After all, our bakery is how we got famous in Fire Island in the first place!

Our Bakery Options

Crumbiest Crumb CakeWhen you come down to our Fire Island bakery, you will have some of the most delicious options at your disposal. Here are some of the most popular items (and their price) Long Islanders love from our bakery:

  • Crumbiest Crumb Cake — 6.5
  • Sfogliatelle — 4.5
  • Rachel's Homemade Toasted Muffin — 4.5
  • Flaky Fresh Baked Turnover (choice of blueberry / cherry / apricot / apple) — 4.75
  • Croissant — 3.95
  • Fresh Baked Biscuits — 3.5

This is just some of what we proudly offer our customers. Get the full bakery experience by coming down to our shop on Fire Island. Fill your cravings with something off our menu that is baked fresh that morning. But hurry! Only while supplies last! It is not uncommon for items to sell out during the day. So if there is something you know you want, coming earlier will guarantee you get it. Otherwise, you run the risk of missing out!

Contact Us Today

Rachel's Fire Island Bakery has been around since 1975. Over the years, we have become more than just a bakery. Since our inception, we have become one of the premier restaurants in the fire island area. But that does not mean we do not appreciate our roots. We love serving fresh basked pastries and cakes to the community.

For more information about our food options, please contact us today. We will happily answer any questions or concerns you may have about all that we have to offer. So please, do not hesitate to give us a call or come on down to our Fire Island bakery. See what all the fuss is about firsthand! We look forward to serving you!

View Our Menus